COMPARE Alberta to ...
U.S. States and Canadian Provinces
Covid-19 numbers - from
places other than Alberta -
only start to become
meaningful when we adjust for population.
This simple tool allows
Albertans to do a quick on-the-spot calculation
--- to more fairly compare any Covid-19 number (tests, cases, deaths, etc.).
--- to more fairly compare any Covid-19 number (tests, cases, deaths, etc.).
Of course, this is just a
starting point in making a comparison.
Other considerations could include – but not be limited to:
population density,
number of tests done,
demographics,
government transparency,
trustworthiness.
Other considerations could include – but not be limited to:
population density,
number of tests done,
demographics,
government transparency,
trustworthiness.
So here's an example of
how to use the following chart:
how to use the following chart:
Let's
first choose to compare Alberta to New York
(the
“actual cases” are fictitious, since they are always changing).
(to find column A or B numbers scroll down).
(to find column A or B numbers scroll down).
#
of actual Alberta cases X Column A
= # Alberta cases at New York's
population level
50 X 4.88 = 244
Now let's choose to
compare New York to Alberta
#
actual New York cases X Column B =
# New York cases at Alberta's
population level
300 X 0.20 = 60
It is now clear, after
accounting for population, that Alberta has a lower number of cases.
Does this necessarily mean
that Alberta is doing better than New York. Maybe. That would take
further study into the number of tests and general trustworthiness of
the numbers that are being provided. But it does give us a general idea of how well we are doing here in Alberta.
3 REASONS why
you should use this method of comparison:
you should use this method of comparison:
- It gets Albertans into a strategy frame of mind. If Albertans are to succeed in the future, we must know ourselves and our neighbours, allies, and opponents. Sun Tsu in The Art of War says, “Carefully compare the opposing army with your own, so that you may know where strength is superabundant and where it is deficient.”
- It is better than a per capita comparison for three reasons. First you know how many more people live in New York state than in Alberta. In a per capita comparison, population differences are hidden from you. Second, most Albertans are most concerned about how Alberta is doing in comparison with everybody else. A list of per capita numbers for every place, for only “one moment in time, is less meaningful. Third, knowing the multiplier (eg. New York state is 4.88 times bigger in population than Alberta), means that every time you get new information, you only have to do “one” quick calculation to make a fairer and more meaningful comparison.
- You learn how Alberta's population – in one or two numbers – compares to any state in the United States (or province in Canada). This wouldn't just be handy for Covid-19 comparisons, but all sorts of comparisons (number of cars, number of hospitals, number of schools, or anything where population plays a role).
- Canadian Provinceor TerritoryColumnAColumnBBritish Columbia1.140.88Manitoba0.313.18New Brunswick0.185.44Newfoundland & Labrador0.137.83Northwest Territories0.0197.33Nova Scotia0.234.4Nunavut0.01113.15Ontario3.310.3Prince Edward Island0.0428.46Quebec2.010.5Saskatchewan0.273.7Yukon0.01113.37
- U.S. StateColumn AColumn BAlabama1.20.83Alaska0.185.5Arizona1.730.58Arkansas0.741.35California9.720.1Colorado1.380.73Connecticut0.881.13Delaware0.244.23District of Columbia0.175.86Florida5.160.19Georgia2.560.39Hawaii0.352.85Idaho0.422.37Illinois3.150.32Indiana1.640.61Iowa0.771.29Kansas0.721.4Kentucky1.10.91Louisiana1.150.87Maine0.333.04Maryland1.490.67Massachusetts1.690.59Michigan2.450.41Minnesota1.370.73Mississsippi0.731.36Missouri1.50.67Montana0.263.87Nebraska0.472.12Nevada0.741.36New Hampshire0.333.03New Jersey2.210.45New Mexico0.511.95New York4.880.2North Carolina2.530.4North Dakota0.195.38Ohio2.870.35Oklahoma0.971.03Oregon1.020.98Pennsylvania3.150.32Puerto Rico (not a state but should be)0.821.22Rhode Island0.263.84South Carolina1.240.81South Dakota0.214.68Tennessee1.650.61Texas6.960.14Utah0.761.31Vermont0.156.52Virginia2.080.48Washington1.820.55West Virginia0.452.24Wisconsin1.420.7Wyoming0.147.02
Sources:
Statistics Canada 2016 Census
US State Populations - Wikipedia
If you like comparing Alberta to other places ...
Watch these YouTubes:
Alberta Northern Superstar
The Shocking Truth about Alberta and Saskatchewan
Comments